News
November 25, 2025 | By MacIver Staff
Policy Issues
Ballot Integrity

Election Integrity Must Trump Access

In an era of open borders and record illegal immigration, one principle should be non-negotiable: only American citizens get to decide America’s future.

Why Aggressive Voter Roll Purges Are the Only Moral Choice

In an era of open borders and record illegal immigration, one principle should be non-negotiable: only American citizens get to decide America’s future. Non-citizen voting is a federal crime, a direct assault on the sacred idea of “one citizen, one vote,” and a quiet theft from every legal voter. Yet for years, many states—especially Democrat-controlled ones—have treated voter rolls like a suggestion rather than a requirement.

The good news? Republican-led states are finally fighting back with aggressive purges, citizenship cross-checks, and proof-of-citizenship laws, removing thousands of ineligible names and proving that integrity and high turnout can coexist. The results are undeniable: cleaner rolls, higher confidence, and zero evidence that asking for proof suppresses anyone who actually belongs at the ballot box.

The Proof Is in the Purges: Real Wins Across Red America

  • Arizona exposed a database glitch that had allowed up to 218,000 voters—5.3 % of the entire rolls—to vote in state races without ever proving citizenship. America First Foundation’s 2025 lawsuit settlement now forces every county to run DHS checks, and thousands are under review.
  • Virginia stripped 6,300 confirmed non-citizens from the rolls since 2022 and purged another 1,600 right before the 2024 election—a move the U.S. Supreme Court upheld.
  • Texas removed over 6,500 non-citizens (nearly 2,000 of whom had already voted) and continues monthly SAVE-database sweeps.
  • Louisiana’s decades-long audit found 390 non-citizens registered and 79 illegal ballots cast—every single one a stolen vote.
  • Ohio, North Carolina, and Florida have all followed suit with hundreds or thousands of removals. Nationwide, states purged 19 million inaccurate records from 2020–2022 alone—a 21 % increase from prior cycles.

 

These aren’t victimless paperwork errors. In states decided by 10,000–20,000 votes, even a few hundred illegal ballots can flip Senate seats, Supreme Court races, or constitutional amendments.

Wisconsin’s Open-Door Democracy: Citizens Need Not Apply

If you want to see what happens when politicians put “access” ahead of integrity, look no further than Wisconsin. Despite a 2024 constitutional amendment declaring only citizens may vote, the Evers administration and the Democrat-controlled Wisconsin Elections Commission still refuse to require proof of citizenship at registration. They won’t run the federal SAVE database that caught thousands of non-citizens in Texas and Virginia. They sued to block a 232,000-name purge in 2019, halted a 69,000-name “likely movers” cleanup in 2021, and in October 2025 rushed to federal court to stop a judge’s order to finally verify all 3.6 million registrants before the 2026 elections.

Their excuse every time? “It’s too hard” and “it might disenfranchise people.” Translation: making sure only citizens vote is less important than keeping registration as frictionless as possible—even if that means leaving the door wide open.

The Bank Analogy No One Can Refute

Imagine walking into a bank and saying, “I’d like to open an account and withdraw $50,000 today.” The teller asks for ID. You reply, “Requiring ID suppresses access to banking!” The bank would laugh you out the door—and rightly so. We demand photo ID and Social Security verification to open a checking account, get a fishing license, buy Sudafed, pick up prescriptions, or board a plane. Yet in Wisconsin and too many blue states, the same politicians insist the ballot box—the one place that decides taxes, borders, and war—should be less secure than a CVS pharmacy. That isn’t compassion; it’s negligence dressed up as virtue.

The “Suppression” Myth Has Been Debunked—Again and Again

The facts destroy the Democratic talking point that integrity measures suppress turnout:

 

  • Texas and Georgia, with the strictest laws in the nation, saw record turnout in 2020, 2022, and 2024—including record Black turnout.
  • After Wisconsin finally implemented photo ID in 2016, turnout increased in every single election that followed.
  • National turnout hit 66.6 % in 2024—the second-highest presidential turnout in 120 years—while more states than ever enforced voter ID and citizenship checks.

 

People who care enough to vote will bring the same ID they already carry everywhere else. The only thing these laws “suppress” is fraud, error, and the quiet cancellation of your legal vote by someone who was never entitled to cast it.

The Bottom Line

Every illegal ballot cancels out a legal one. Every non-citizen on the rolls dilutes the voice of a veteran, a single mom, a senior on a fixed income—real citizens who play by the rules. States that aggressively purge ineligibles aren’t attacking democracy; they’re defending it. States like Wisconsin that refuse to verify citizenship aren’t expanding access; they’re gambling with our Republic.

It’s time to treat voting with the same seriousness we treat banking, flying, and buying beer.

Pass the SAVE Act nationally.

Require proof of citizenship at registration everywhere.

Purge relentlessly and transparently.

Because if the ballot box isn’t reserved for citizens only, then nothing else in this country truly belongs to us either.

Our elections. Our country. Citizens only.

Interested in the content of this Article?

Reach out to the MacIver Institute to aquire more information